---
title: "Auction Condition Reports Explained: Grades, Lights, Limits"
description: "What an auction condition report and its 0 to 5 grade cover, what the green, yellow, red and blue lights mean, and why no report replaces your own check."
canonical: https://texas.huntautogroup.com/guides/auction-condition-reports-explained/
last_updated: 2026-11-19
language: en
---

# Auction Condition Reports Explained: Grades, Lights, Limits



Auctions

# Auction Condition Reports Explained: Grades, Lights, Limits

What an auction condition report and its 0 to 5 grade cover, what the green, yellow, red and blue lights mean, and why no report replaces your own check.

**[Anthony Hunt](https://texas.huntautogroup.com/about/) ** Updated November 19, 202610 min read

![Auction Condition Reports Explained: Grades, Lights, Limits](https://texas.huntautogroup.com/assets/covers/auction-condition-reports-explained.webp)

An auction condition report is an inspector's record of a vehicle's visible condition, often summarized as a grade on a 0.0 to 5.0 scale. It is built mainly around cosmetic damage, so mechanical and electrical problems may not be listed. Auctions themselves say never to buy on the grade alone; read the damage list, the seller's announcements, and run your own title and recall checks.

This guide explains how condition reports work at wholesale auctions like Manheim, what the announcement lights mean, what public and salvage auctions usually provide instead, and how to use a report if a dealer shows you one.

## What a condition report is

At wholesale auctions, a condition report (CR) is a structured inspection with photos. Manheim's buyer help page explains the basics ([Manheim new dealer buyer help](https://site.manheim.com/en/help/new-dealer-registration/new-dealer-buyer.html) ):

- A CR indicator on a listing means a report exists. If a grade is present, a trained inspector reviewed the vehicle.

- The grade uses the National Auto Auction Association (NAAA) grading scale of 0.0 to 5.0.

- The inspector does not choose the grade. The damage recorded sets it.

- Inspectors are trained to find and classify visible cosmetic damage. In some instances they may note mechanical and electrical damage.

- Inspectors also note the lights present and take pictures.

Manheim tells buyers: "You should never make a buying decision on a Condition Report grade alone." It advises reading the damage items, the announcements and the seller comments.

### What a report usually covers

| Usually covered | Often limited or not covered |
| --- | --- |
| Dents, scratches, chips, panel damage | Engine and transmission health |
| Glass, wheels and tire condition as seen | Electrical faults that do not show a warning light |
| Interior wear, stains, tears | How the car drives at highway speed |
| Warning lights shown on the dash | Hidden frame or flood damage |
| Photos of damage | Areas the inspector cannot reach |

The left column describes what Manheim says its inspectors are trained to record. The right column is a reminder of what a visual inspection cannot confirm. Manheim itself suggests buyers request purchase protection for areas inspectors cannot inspect.

## Announcement lights

At Manheim, in-lane and Simulcast sales use announcement lights. Sellers follow the NAAA Arbitration Guidelines when choosing a light ([Manheim new dealer buyer help](https://site.manheim.com/en/help/new-dealer-registration/new-dealer-buyer.html) ):

| Light | What the seller represents |
| --- | --- |
| Green | Vehicle is free of known major arbitrable defects |
| Green with yellow | Free of known major defects except what the seller announces |
| Yellow | Sold under an announced condition |
| Red | Sold "As IS" |
| Blue | Title is not present at the time of sale |

A green light is a representation about known defects, not a warranty of condition. A blue light means the title is not there yet, which can delay registration.

**Want a personalized car guide?**Message Anthony on WhatsApp with your budget and what you need. Free, honest advice in English or Spanish. He doesn't sell cars.[WhatsApp](https://wa.me/15559374868?text=Hi%20Anthony%2C%20I%27d%20like%20a%20personalized%20car%20guide%20%28I%20read%3A%20Auction%20Condition%20Reports%20Explained%3A%20Grades%2C%20Lights%2C%20Limits%29.)

## Arbitration: the dealer's safety net

Wholesale auctions offer arbitration, where the auction acts as a neutral intermediary on certain disputes. Outcomes can include a price adjustment or a cancelled sale. Deadlines are short. Manheim requires in-lane purchase claims by close of business on sale day, and gives Simulcast and timed-sale buyers 10 calendar days from the sale date, with the sale date counting as day one ([Manheim arbitration timelines](https://site.manheim.com/en/marketplace-policies/us-policies/arbitration-process-timelines.html) ).

These are terms between the auction and its dealer buyers. A consumer who later buys the car from a dealer is not a party to them.

## What public and salvage auctions provide

Public auctions may not offer a graded condition report at all. Ask each auction what it provides.

- **Public consumer auctions** in the corridor offer previews. [Metro Auto Auction](https://www.metroautoauction.com) in Dale lists weekday preview hours. [Public Auto Auctions](https://carstrucksandboats.com) in Kyle states items are sold as-is with no warranty.

- **Government surplus** listings are written by the selling agency or platform; read every line. TxDOT says its surplus is sold as-is and sales are final ([TxDOT surplus](https://www.txdot.gov/business/surplus-and-salvage-of-state-property.html) ).

- **Salvage auctions** such as IAA and Copart sell mostly damaged and total-loss vehicles. Any damage description on a lot is not a full inspection. See [salvage auctions: Copart and IAA risks](https://texas.huntautogroup.com/guides/salvage-auctions-copart-iaa-risks/) .

- **Police impound auctions** usually offer the least information. See [police impound auctions](https://texas.huntautogroup.com/guides/police-impound-auctions-austin-san-antonio/) .

If an auction offers no report, the preview is your report. Bring a flashlight, an OBD-II scan tool if you have one, and someone who knows cars.

## How to read an auction condition report

1. **Match the VIN.** Confirm the VIN on the report matches the VIN on the car and the title.

1. **Read the damage list, not just the grade.** Two cars with the same grade can have very different problems.

1. **Look at every photo.** Check for paint color differences between panels, uneven gaps and overspray.

1. **Note the odometer and compare it with the title record.** See [odometer fraud: how to check](https://texas.huntautogroup.com/guides/odometer-fraud-how-to-check/) .

1. **Read announcements and seller comments.** Words like "frame damage," "flood," "mileage" or "no title" change everything.

1. **Check warning lights.** A recorded check-engine or airbag light needs a diagnosis, not a guess.

1. **Run the VIN.** Use [TxDMV Title Check](https://www.txdmv.gov/motorists/buying-or-selling-a-vehicle/title-check-look-before-you-buy) for salvage, flood, rebuilt, odometer and buyback brands, and [NHTSA.gov/recalls](https://www.nhtsa.gov/recalls) for open recalls.

1. **Assume anything not listed is unknown,** not "fine."

### A worked example with two hypothetical reports

The numbers below are made up to show how the rules work. They are not real listings.

Say two similar sedans both show a grade of 3.5. Report A lists a door ding, light scratches on the rear bumper and worn front tires, with a green light. Report B lists the same grade, but its damage items include a repainted front fender, a check-engine light on the dash, and an announcement that reads "structural damage," with a yellow light.

On grade alone, the two cars look equal. On the details, they are not. Report A is a cosmetic list. Report B points to a past repair, an unknown engine fault and a frame issue, and the yellow light means the car sells under that announced condition. This is exactly why Manheim tells buyers never to decide on the grade alone ([Manheim new dealer buyer help](https://site.manheim.com/en/help/new-dealer-registration/new-dealer-buyer.html) ). The grade is a summary. The damage list, the lights and the announcements are the substance.

## Step by step: using a report before you bid or buy

This order works whether you are previewing a public sale, reading a dealer's printout, or checking a listing online.

1. **Save a copy of the report and the listing.** Screenshots or PDFs keep a record of what was represented on the day.

1. **Write down the VIN from the report.** Then find the VIN plate on the dash and the sticker on the driver door jamb and confirm all three match.

1. **Run the VIN through TxDMV Title Check.** It uses NMVTIS and shows brands such as salvage, rebuilt, water damage and odometer problems, and whether an insurer declared the car a total loss ([TxDMV Title Check](https://www.txdmv.gov/motorists/buying-or-selling-a-vehicle/title-check-look-before-you-buy) ).

1. **Run the VIN at NHTSA.** Open recalls are not always fixed before a used car is sold, so look them up yourself ([NHTSA recalls](https://www.nhtsa.gov/recalls) ).

1. **Compare the report photos with the car in person.** Look for damage the photos did not show and for damage that has been touched up since.

1. **Check the light and announcements again on sale day.** A light or announcement can differ from what you saw online.

1. **List the unknowns.** Engine, transmission, suspension, air conditioning and anything the inspector could not reach.

1. **Set your walk-away rule before bidding.** If the unknowns are too large for your budget to absorb, skip the car.

## Common mistakes with condition reports

- **Treating the grade like a school score.** A higher number means less recorded damage, not a better engine.

- **Skipping the announcements.** A short phrase in the announcements can matter more than the whole damage list.

- **Ignoring a blue light.** Title not present at the time of sale can delay registration. In Texas, a private buyer has 30 days to title a vehicle, and late filing adds a penalty ([TxDMV buying or selling a vehicle](https://www.txdmv.gov/motorists/buying-or-selling-a-vehicle) ). Plan around a missing title before you buy, not after.

- **Assuming arbitration protects you.** Manheim's arbitration deadlines and rules apply to its dealer buyers ([Manheim arbitration timelines](https://site.manheim.com/en/marketplace-policies/us-policies/arbitration-process-timelines.html) ), not to a consumer at a public sale.

- **Buying on photos in Texas summer light.** Bright sun hides paint mismatches and small dents. Look at panels from an angle and in shade if you can.

- **Forgetting the auction's own terms.** Public sales in the corridor can be as-is with no warranty, as the Kyle auction states on its site ([Public Auto Auctions](https://carstrucksandboats.com) ).

## Local notes: auctions around Austin and San Antonio

The kind of report you see depends on who is allowed to buy.

| Auction | Location | Who can buy (per its site) |
| --- | --- | --- |
| [Manheim San Antonio](https://site.manheim.com/en/states/texas) | 2042 Ackerman Rd, San Antonio | Dealers, enrolled through AuctionACCESS |
| [ADESA San Antonio](https://www.adesa.com/san-antonio) | 200 S. Callaghan Road, San Antonio | Dealer registration |
| [America's Auto Auction Austin](https://americasaa.com/locations/austin/) | 16611 S I-35 Frontage Rd, Buda | Wholesale, dealers in-lane |
| [Alliance Auto Auction Austin](https://www.allianceautoauction.com/) | 1550 CR 107, Hutto | Wholesale dealers |
| [Metro Auto Auction](https://www.metroautoauction.com) | 2221 Hwy 21 W, Dale | Public online auction |
| [Public Auto Auctions](https://carstrucksandboats.com) | 12253 Camino Real, Kyle | Dealers, repair shops and the public |
| [IAA Austin](https://www.iaai.com/us/Locations/418) | 2191 Highway 21 West, Dale | Public Buyer accounts, for lots open to the public |
| [IAA San Antonio-South](https://www.iaai.com/us/Locations/442) | 11275 S. Zarzamora St., San Antonio | Public Buyer accounts, for lots open to the public |

At the dealer-only lanes, a full CR with lights and arbitration is normal, but you cannot bid there yourself. See [can the public buy at Manheim](https://texas.huntautogroup.com/guides/can-the-public-buy-at-manheim/) . At the public sales in Dale and Kyle, plan to rely on the preview. At IAA, a public account sees only the inventory available to the public, and other lots need a licensed account or a broker ([IAA: who can buy](https://www.iaai.com/us/Articles/online-car-auctions-who-can-buy) ). The full list is on the [auctions hub](https://texas.huntautogroup.com/auctions/) .

## What I would do

If I were looking at an auction car with a report, I would read it backward: announcements and lights first, then the damage list, then the photos, and the grade last. I would treat every blank line as "not checked," not "no problem." I would run Title Check and the NHTSA recall lookup before I spent a minute on price.

At a public sale with no report, I would go to the preview, bring a flashlight and a basic OBD-II reader, and bring a friend who knows cars. I would only bid on a car I could afford to repair, because "as-is" means the repair bill is mine. And if a dealer handed me an auction report on a retail car, I would thank them, read it, and still book my own [pre-purchase inspection](https://texas.huntautogroup.com/guides/pre-purchase-inspection-checklist/) . For the bigger picture on bidding, I would also read [how car auctions work in Texas](https://texas.huntautogroup.com/guides/how-car-auctions-work-in-texas/) .

## If a dealer shows you an auction report

Some dealers share the auction condition report for cars on their lot. It can help, but:

- The report describes the car on auction day, before any reconditioning.

- It was written for a dealer buyer and is mostly cosmetic.

- It is not a warranty to you. Your protections come from your sales contract and the FTC Buyers Guide on the window, which shows whether the car is sold as-is or with a warranty and overrides contrary terms in the contract ([FTC Dealer's Guide to the Used Car Rule](https://www.ftc.gov/business-guidance/resources/dealers-guide-used-car-rule) ).

Still get your own [pre-purchase inspection](https://texas.huntautogroup.com/guides/pre-purchase-inspection-checklist/) from a mechanic you choose.

## Sources

- [Manheim - New dealer buyer help (condition reports and announcement lights)](https://site.manheim.com/en/help/new-dealer-registration/new-dealer-buyer.html)

- [Manheim - Arbitration process timelines](https://site.manheim.com/en/marketplace-policies/us-policies/arbitration-process-timelines.html)

- [Metro Auto Auction](https://www.metroautoauction.com)

- [Public Auto Auctions, Kyle](https://carstrucksandboats.com)

- [TxDOT - Surplus and salvage of state property](https://www.txdot.gov/business/surplus-and-salvage-of-state-property.html)

- [TxDMV - Title Check: Look Before You Buy](https://www.txdmv.gov/motorists/buying-or-selling-a-vehicle/title-check-look-before-you-buy)

- [NHTSA - Recalls](https://www.nhtsa.gov/recalls)

- [FTC - Dealer's Guide to the Used Car Rule](https://www.ftc.gov/business-guidance/resources/dealers-guide-used-car-rule)

- [TxDMV - Buying or selling a vehicle](https://www.txdmv.gov/motorists/buying-or-selling-a-vehicle)

- [Manheim - Texas locations](https://site.manheim.com/en/states/texas)

- [ADESA San Antonio](https://www.adesa.com/san-antonio)

- [America's Auto Auction Austin](https://americasaa.com/locations/austin/)

- [Alliance Auto Auction](https://www.allianceautoauction.com/)

- [IAA Austin](https://www.iaai.com/us/Locations/418)

- [IAA San Antonio-South](https://www.iaai.com/us/Locations/442)

- [IAA - Who can buy at online car auctions](https://www.iaai.com/us/Articles/online-car-auctions-who-can-buy)

## Frequently asked questions

**What is a good auction condition report grade?**

Manheim uses the NAAA 0.0 to 5.0 scale, and the recorded damage sets the grade, not the inspector. Manheim says never to buy on the grade alone, because the report focuses on cosmetic condition.

**Does a condition report check the engine?**

Not as a rule. Manheim says its inspectors are trained to find visible cosmetic damage and may note mechanical and electrical damage only in some instances. Have a mechanic check the engine and transmission.

**What does a red light mean at a car auction?**

At Manheim, a red light means the vehicle is sold "As IS." A yellow light means it is sold under an announced condition, and a blue light means the title is not present at the time of sale.

**Can I use auction arbitration as a consumer?**

No. Arbitration is between the auction and its dealer buyers. If you buy from a dealer, your rights come from your contract, the Buyers Guide and Texas law.

**Do public auctions give condition reports?**

Ask each auction. Many public sales rely on photos, a written description or a preview, so treat the preview as your inspection.

**What does a blue light mean on an auction condition report?**

At Manheim, a blue light means the title is not present at the time of sale. That can delay titling and registration, so confirm when the title will arrive before you count on driving the car.

Educational content. Anthony does not sell, broker or arrange vehicle sales in Texas. Confirm fees and rules with the office named in each source before you pay anything.

## Want a personalized car guide?

Message Anthony on WhatsApp with your budget and what you need. Free, honest advice in English or Spanish. He doesn't sell cars.

[WhatsApp Anthony](https://wa.me/15559374868?text=Hi%20Anthony%2C%20I%27d%20like%20a%20personalized%20car%20guide%20%28I%20read%3A%20Auction%20Condition%20Reports%20Explained%3A%20Grades%2C%20Lights%2C%20Limits%29.) [Ask Anthony](https://texas.huntautogroup.com/contact/)

### Related articles

![Buying a Car at Auction in Texas: A Step-by-Step Checklist](https://texas.huntautogroup.com/assets/covers/buying-a-car-at-auction-checklist-640.webp)

[AuctionsBuying a Car at Auction in Texas: A Step-by-Step ChecklistBuying a car at auction in Texas, step by step: a checklist for public, government and salvage auctions, from registration to title.November 19, 2026](https://texas.huntautogroup.com/guides/buying-a-car-at-auction-checklist/)

![Can the Public Buy at Manheim? What Texas Buyers Should Know](https://texas.huntautogroup.com/assets/covers/can-the-public-buy-at-manheim-640.webp)

[AuctionsCan the Public Buy at Manheim? What Texas Buyers Should KnowCan the public buy at Manheim? No. Why Manheim, ADESA and OPENLANE are dealer-only, why paid access offers break Texas law, and where to buy instead.November 5, 2026](https://texas.huntautogroup.com/guides/can-the-public-buy-at-manheim/)

![Dealer-Only vs Public Car Auctions in Texas Explained](https://texas.huntautogroup.com/assets/covers/dealer-only-vs-public-car-auctions-640.webp)

[AuctionsDealer-Only vs Public Car Auctions in Texas ExplainedHow dealer-only auctions like Manheim and ADESA differ from public car auctions near Austin and San Antonio, and why a license gap cannot be bought.November 5, 2026](https://texas.huntautogroup.com/guides/dealer-only-vs-public-car-auctions/)

![Anthony Hunt](https://texas.huntautogroup.com/assets/anthony-hunt-320.webp)

### Anthony Hunt

Web developer and car enthusiast in Austin, Texas. Anthony has spent the last year and a half around used cars and auctions, digs into every rule and recall so you don't have to, and knows people across the car business. Need help choosing a car? Ask him, it's free.

[anthonyhunts.com](https://anthonyhunts.com)
